Target, Wegman’s top Greenpeace’s report card for seafood sales

If we're going to have anything approaching a sustainable seafood system, we need to combine personal adherence to seafood lists with moves up the supply chain to the big buyers, the wholesalers, and supermarkets that sell the bulk of the seafood. Whereas wholesalers primarily work in the background, their presence made known only by logo'd trucks and subdued packaging in restaurant storerooms, the big chain supermarkets are everywhere, fighting the daily battle for new customers and to keep their current ones. And so they care about their public image, which makes campaigns like Best/Worst lists, Pass/Fail lists, or targeting specific chains  important tactics, as recommended by a paper in Oryx that I reviewed here. Exhibit A: the "Traitor Joe" campaign that likely influenced in Trader Joe's recent seafood shift.

For several years, as part of a project called Carting Away the Oceans (PDF), Greenpeace has been grading supermarkets' seafood practices. A few weeks ago the group released the 2010 update. Progress has been impressive: in 2008, not a single chain received a passing grade; in 2010, half of the 20 chains surveyed passed. Target took the top rating, followed by Wegman's, Whole Foods, and the Safeway conglomerate (Safeway, Von's, Dominick's, Genuardi's, Pavilions, and Randall's). Thanks to its new seafood policy, Trader Joe's improved from a failing grade to a passing one. The worst rated were Publix, Winn Dixie, Meijer, and H.E. Butt (operator of H.E.B. and Central Market).

Greenpeace grades the chains on four criteria (using methods that aren't fully explained in the report), with the final result being "good," "pass," or "fail":

  1. Sustainable seafood policy - Does the company have a policy that guides its purchases? Is it publicly available? Is it worthwhile?
  2. Initiatives and partnerships - Is the company involved in the political process around marine ecosystems and fishing? Is it a member of groups like the Food Marketing Institute’s Sustainability Task Force?
  3. Transparency - How good is the labeling and signage in the seafood department? Can a shopper easily determine the species (preferably with labels using the Latin name), where the fish was caught, and how it was caught? Is the staff trained in sustainability subjects?
  4. Red-list species - How many red-list species — ones that Greenpeace considers to be overfished or caught using methods that destroy marine ecosystems (e.g., bottom trawling), from poorly managed fisheries, or by pirate fishing vessels — are sold in the stores?

To illustrate some of the logic behind the rankings, I'll explain how the chain with the second-highest rating and the three chains with the worst ratings performed on each of the four criteria. First, Wegman's, the second-best-ranked chain:

  1. Policy – Wegman's has a publicly available policy that specifies the company's requirements for wild-caught and farmed seafood. It is also the first retailer that has pledged not to purchase seafood from the Ross Sea, "the most pristine shallow sea on the planet," according to the Greenpeace report.
  2. Initiatives - The company's chain of custody is certified by the Marine Stewardship Council, it is working with the Environmental Defense Fund, is part of the Food Marketing Institute’s sustainability initiative, and supports the “Common Vision for Environmentally Sustainable Seafood,” an initiative of the Conservation Alliance for Seafood Solutions.
  3. Transparency - Provides sustainability information to shoppers and trains its staff about seafood sustainability.
  4. Red-list species – This is an area that needs some work, as Wegman's was selling 15 of the 22 species at the time of the survey.

The bottom three chains – Winn-Dixie, Meijer, and H.E. Butt – all failed to respond to Greenpeace's inquiries.  Their situations are basically identical:

  1. Policy - No publicly available policy (and if there is a private policy, they didn't tell Greenpeace about it)
  2. Initiatives - The companies are not affiliated with any sustainability working group or third-party certifier
  3. Transparency - Labeling is inadequate, no attempts made to educate customers about sustainability
  4. Red-list species - H.E. Butt sells 16 of the 22 red-list species, Winn-Dixie sells 12, and Meijer sells 14.

One shortcoming of the Greenpeace study is that all of the chains are essentially equivalent on the report card even though they represent a diversity of geography, revenue, and clientele.  For example, while Target and Whole Foods have great ratings, seafood sales at the lower-ranked chains might be much higher in volume, which somewhat diminishes the good grade and heightens the bad grade as far as the fish are concerned. However, actually creating such a weighting is probably impossible, as seafood sales figures for each grocery chain are not made public.

Still, the Carting Away the Oceans is a tool that can amplify personal seafood guides like Monterey Bay Aquarium's Seafood Watch guide by helping shoppers move up the supply chain and vote with their dollars — or perhaps start their own campaign to improve seafood sustainability at their local grocery store.

Photo by http://www.flickr.com/photos/klara/ / CC BY-NC-SA 2.0

3 Responsesto “Target, Wegman’s top Greenpeace’s report card for seafood sales”

  1. Very informative. I wonder how Giant Foods on the east coast ranks?  I find it really hard to get sustainability information from certain stores, they really should be required to display it like Wegman's.

  2. Arpita --
    Giant, which is owned by the Netherlands-based Royal Ahold company, is in the top tier, with a ranking of 6 out of a possible 10 putting it at the upper end of the "pass" category.  Greenpeace notes that "Ahold continues to be a leader in sustainable seafood within the US industry." They have a sound seafood sourcing policy, make the policy publicly available, chair the Food Marketing Institute’s Sustainable Seafood Working Group, and supposedly have in-store information about seafood sustainability. However, as you note a difficulty in finding information, perhaps the signage still needs improvement. Ahold-owned stores sell 13 of the 22 species on Greenpeace's red list.

    The Royal Ahold company operates 700 grocery stores along the East Coast and in New England under the names Stop & Shop, Martin’s Food Market, Ukrop’s and Giant.

  3. Thank You! That was really good to know.